A contractor called me last week with a question I hear frequently: "Lance, we've got three major projects starting next quarter, but I can't afford three full-time safety managers. What do I do?"
After nearly three decades in the safety profession (starting in the petrochemical industry in 1996 and founding SafetyPro Resources in 2005) I can tell you the question isn't whether safety matters. The real question is how to staff your safety needs most effectively.
The stakes couldn't be higher. According to the Bureau of Labor Statistics, a total of 1,075 construction workers died on the job in 2023. Nearly 1 in 5 workplace deaths in the United States occurs in construction. Your safety staffing decisions directly impact these statistics, your bottom line, and your ability to win bids.
What You'll Learn About Safety Staffing vs Full-Time Safety Managers
In this guide, I'm going to share what I've learned through my experience across petrochemical, construction, healthcare, chemical processing, refineries, power generation, and shipyards:
- What safety staffing means and when to use it
- The role and value of a full-time safety manager
- Key cost and flexibility trade-offs
- When a hybrid model makes the most sense
- How SafetyPro's staffing and recruiting service works
- Critical questions to ask safety staffing agencies
- A practical decision framework
Understanding Safety Staffing
Safety staffing means bringing in safety professionals on a temporary or project-based basis rather than hiring them as permanent employees. Think of it as having access to experienced safety experts exactly when you need them, without the long-term commitment.
At SafetyPro, we offer both short-term and long-term safety staffing solutions designed specifically for construction and industrial projects. Here's what typically happens:
Rapid Deployment: Instead of spending weeks recruiting and interviewing, you can have a qualified safety professional on your site within days. I've deployed safety professionals to client sites in as little as 48 hours when the situation demanded it.
Rigorous Vetting: At SafetyPro, we carefully screen all safety professionals through comprehensive background checks, reference verification, and credential validation. As a Certified Safety Professional myself, I know what credentials matter and how to verify them properly.
Payroll Management: The agency handles all payroll responsibilities — wages, taxes, workers' compensation insurance, and benefits administration. This alone saves clients countless hours each month.
Specialized Expertise: Throughout my career working in everything from petrochemical facilities to construction sites, I've learned that different projects need different expertise. Whether you need expertise in confined space entry, fall protection, or Process Safety Management, staffing gives you access to the right specialist for each situation.
The Role of a Full-Time Safety Manager
A full-time safety manager serves as the cornerstone of your organization's safety culture. According to OSHA, construction managers apply comprehensive project controls to help manage the critical issues of time, cost, scope, quality, and safety.
Through my work as Louisiana Area Director for the American Society of Safety Professionals and Chairman of the Associated General Contractors of Louisiana Safety Committee, I've seen what the best full-time safety managers do:
- Develop comprehensive safety management systems
- Conduct regular audits and inspections
- Deliver ongoing employee safety training
- Investigate incidents to prevent recurrence
- Stay current with evolving OSHA regulations
- Champion safety culture throughout the organization
The strategic advantage? They understand your company's unique risk profile, know your employees by name, and can anticipate safety challenges specific to your operations.
Cost Comparison for Safety Staffing vs Full-Time Safety Managers: The Real Numbers<
Let me get into the real numbers, because understanding true costs requires looking beyond surface-level figures. I've reviewed countless budgets over my career, so I can show you what companies often miss.
Safety Staffing Costs
When you engage safety staffing services, your costs typically include the hourly or daily rate plus any travel expenses for on-site work. According to industry data, staffing markups range from 25% to 100% depending on specialty, experience required, and special requirements. At SafetyPro, I structure our rates to be competitive while ensuring we can provide top-quality professionals.
However, you only pay for time worked or until the project is completed. More importantly, the staffing firm absorbs taxes, insurance, and administrative fees. You avoid:
- Health insurance and retirement benefits
- Paid time off and sick leave
- Unemployment insurance
- Workers' compensation premiums
- Ongoing professional development costs
- Recruiting and hiring expenses
Full-Time Manager Costs
Based on 2025 salary data, the average construction safety manager earns $88,480 annually. But as someone who's been in this industry since 1996, I can tell you this base salary represents only part of the total cost:
- Base Salary: $80,000-$95,000 depending on region and experience
- Benefits Package: $25,000-$40,000 additional (health insurance, retirement, PTO)
- Payroll Taxes: 20-30% on top of base salary (Social Security, Medicare, unemployment, workers' comp)
- Recruiting and Onboarding: $5,000-$15,000 one-time cost
- Ongoing Training: $2,000-$5,000 annually to maintain certifications
- Equipment and Workspace: Computer, phone, vehicle allowance, safety equipment
Total first-year cost: Often $130,000-$150,000 or more. In subsequent years, expect $110,000-$130,000 annually.
Hidden Costs That Add Up
Utilization Rate: Here's something I explain to every client. A full-time safety manager draws a salary whether you have one project or ten. During slow periods, you're paying for capacity you're not using. I've seen companies struggle with this during economic downturns. With staffing, you only pay for the time worked, making contract workers cost much less than salaried employees when workload fluctuates.
Bad Hire Costs: I've seen this hurt companies badly. The cost of a bad hire can be extremely costly to your business — one study found it averages 30% of the employee's first-year salary. Terminating a full-time employee involves legal risks, potential unemployment claims, severance costs, and lost productivity during the search for a replacement. With staffing, if someone isn't performing adequately, I can address it immediately and provide a replacement if needed.
Opportunity Costs: The time your leadership spends recruiting, interviewing, onboarding, and managing a full-time employee has real cost, even if it's not always quantified. I've watched executives spend 40+ hours hiring a safety manager — time that could have been spent on revenue-generating activities.
When to Choose Each Approach
Based on my experience founding SafetyPro and working with companies across multiple industries since 1996, here's when each model makes sense. I've helped hundreds of companies make this decision, so I can give you practical guidance.
Choose Safety Staffing If You Have:
Fluctuating Project Pipelines: If your project pipeline isn't steady, staffing provides the flexibility to match safety coverage to actual need. Many construction companies experience seasonal fluctuations based on weather, client budgets, or market conditions. Staffing lets them scale perfectly without carrying overhead during slow periods.
Peak Demand Phases: During shutdowns, turnarounds, or major expansions, you may need multiple safety professionals on-site for weeks or months. I've managed major turnarounds at refineries where we brought in a full team of safety specialists for 8-12 weeks, then scaled back when the work completed. For projects requiring immediate compliance with OSHA's confined space regulations, temporary certified staff can ensure adherence while training your internal team.
Specialized Safety Needs: When you're working with unique hazards — confined space entry, high-angle rescue, hazardous materials handling, or Process Safety Management — you need specialists with specific certifications. Throughout my career in petrochemical and power generation, I've developed expertise in high-hazard work. Staffing lets you bring in the right expert for the right job.
Multiple Simultaneous Projects: If you run multiple projects across different locations, staffing allows you to deploy safety coverage where needed without hiring separate full-time managers for each site.
Geographic Expansion: When entering new markets, staffing lets you establish safety presence while you learn about local requirements. I've helped several Louisiana contractors expand into Texas, Mississippi, and Alabama using this approach.
Budget Constraints: For smaller contractors or those experiencing cash flow challenges, the pay-as-you-go model of staffing can be more manageable than the fixed overhead of full-time salary plus benefits.
Choose a Full-Time Manager If You Have:
Stable, Year-Round Operations: If your company maintains continuous operations with consistent safety demands, a full-time manager provides steady oversight. Manufacturing facilities and companies with steady backlog benefit most from this model.
Safety as Competitive Advantage: Companies viewing safety as a competitive differentiator benefit from having a dedicated champion. As Chairman of the AGC Louisiana Safety Committee, I've seen how this makes a real difference in winning bids.
Complex Compliance Requirements: If your operations involve multiple facilities or extensive regulatory requirements (like Process Safety Management in petrochemical), you need someone fully dedicated to managing these complexities.
Long-Term Culture Building: When you want to develop mature safety culture through consistent training, coaching, and employee engagement, a full-time manager provides the needed continuity. Safety culture requires years of consistent leadership.
Client or Owner Mandates: Some clients require contractors to have dedicated full-time safety staff as a condition of contract awards. This is common in petrochemical, power generation, and federal projects.
Choose a Hybrid Approach If You Have:
Variable But Predictable Workload: You have baseline safety needs plus periodic, somewhat predictable spikes in demand.
Mixed Project Types: Your operations involve both steady-state maintenance work and specialized projects. The full-time manager handles routine work, while temporary specialists handle complex, short-duration projects.
Growth Trajectory: You're growing and want to build toward a complete safety department over time. Start with one full-time manager, supplement with staffing, and add positions as your business scales.
The Hybrid Model: My Recommended Approach
Here's where I get excited, because I've seen the hybrid model work beautifully for so many clients over the past two decades. The hybrid model involves employing one full-time safety manager for core needs while supplementing with temporary professionals during peak periods or for specialized requirements.
How It Works in Practice
A typical hybrid model looks like this: employ a full-time Safety Director who handles program development, monthly safety management, compliance documentation, training programs, and culture building. This person serves as your safety champion and maintains continuity.
Then, when you land a major turnaround project, face a seasonal surge, or need specialized expertise, bring in temporary safety coordinators or specialists through SafetyPro's staffing service for additional on-site coverage. These temporary professionals handle the tactical, boots-on-the-ground work while your full-time manager maintains strategic oversight.
Real-World Success Story
Let me share an example that's typical of what I see — details changed for confidentiality, but the numbers are real.
One client, a regional contractor specializing in industrial maintenance and construction with 75 employees, maintains one full-time safety manager year-round at a total cost of about $120,000 annually. This manager handles all ongoing safety needs: program development, regular training, compliance management, and safety culture.
Twice annually, this company wins major turnaround projects lasting 8-12 weeks that require intensive safety oversight. During these periods, they need 2-3 additional safety professionals on-site to manage the influx of subcontractors, coordinate daily safety briefings, conduct inspections, and ensure compliance across complex, rapidly changing worksites.
Rather than maintaining three full-time safety managers year-round — with an associated cost of $360,000+ annually — the company uses SafetyPro's staffing for these turnaround periods. The temporary staffing for both turnarounds costs approximately $90,000 total for the year.
Total annual safety staffing cost: $210,000 (one full-time manager plus temporary support) Cost of three full-time managers: $360,000+ Annual savings: $150,000+
Result: They maintain safety excellence during peak periods while keeping costs manageable during normal operations. I've personally placed these professionals and monitored their performance — the model works.
Why the Hybrid Model Succeeds
Optimal Resource Utilization: You maintain essential safety leadership while scaling tactical support based on actual demand. This is just smart business, in my opinion.
Access to Specialized Expertise: Your full-time manager may be excellent at program development but lack specific technical expertise — say, in Process Safety Management for a chemical plant turnaround or high-angle rescue for a bridge project. Temporary specialists fill these gaps perfectly. Throughout my career in petrochemical, construction, and power generation, I've developed deep expertise in multiple areas, and I can match the right specialist to your specific needs.
Cost Control: You avoid paying full-time salaries and benefits for capacity you only need periodically, while maintaining the continuity that comes from permanent leadership. After working with companies across the Gulf Coast since 2005, I can tell you this approach consistently delivers the best value.
Flexibility During Transitions: If your full-time safety manager leaves unexpectedly — and I've helped several clients navigate this situation — you can bring in temporary coverage immediately while you conduct a proper search for a permanent replacement. This prevents gaps in safety coverage that could lead to incidents or compliance issues.
How SafetyPro Facilitates the Hybrid Model
I designed SafetyPro's service structure to make this straightforward:
- Vetted Professionals: All staff undergo rigorous screening — background checks, credential verification, reference checks
- Payroll Handling: We manage all payroll, tax, and benefits administration
- Quick Deployment: Typically 3-5 business days, sometimes 48 hours for urgent needs
- Scalable Support: From one professional for two weeks to five specialists for six months
- Recruitment Services: When you're ready to hire permanent staff, our recruiting services identify and vet top candidates
Critical Questions to Ask Staffing Agencies
After 30 years in this business, here are the questions I'd ask if I were choosing a safety staffing partner:
Qualification Questions:
- How do you verify credentials and certifications? (At SafetyPro, I verify directly with BCSP and OSHA training institutes)
- What experience do your professionals have in my specific industry?
- What's your screening process? (Background checks, drug screening, reference verification?)
Service Questions:
- What's your typical response time? (I typically deploy within 3-5 business days)
- Do you provide both temporary and permanent recruitment?
- Who handles payroll, taxes, and insurance? (Should always be the agency)
- What if a professional isn't performing adequately?
Compliance Questions:
- What insurance coverage do you carry?
- How do you stay current with OSHA regulations?
- Can you support procurement database requirements (Avetta, ISNetworld)?
What You Get Working with SafetyPro
Let me tell you what makes SafetyPro different. I founded this company in 2005 based on what I learned in my first decade working in safety:
Rigorous Vetting: Every professional undergoes comprehensive background checks, credential verification, reference checks, and competency assessments. I use the same standards I'd apply for my own permanent staff.
Industry Expertise: Our professionals bring experience from construction, petrochemical, manufacturing, and other high-hazard industries. You get personnel who understand your specific challenges — not generalists learning on your job site.
Complete Service Integration: SafetyPro isn't just staffing — we're a full-service safety consulting firm offering:
- Safety auditing and compliance reviews
- Construction safety management
- Employee safety training programs
- Monthly safety management services
- Custom safety program development
Frequently Asked Questions
Q: Is safety staffing more expensive than hiring full-time?
A: It depends on utilization. For consistent year-round needs, full-time may be more cost-effective. For fluctuating or project-based needs, staffing typically costs less overall because you only pay for time worked.
Q: How quickly can SafetyPro deploy someone?
A: Typically 3-5 business days, sometimes 48 hours for emergencies. This is possible because I maintain a network of pre-vetted, certified professionals.
Q: Are your professionals certified?
A: Absolutely. Our staff hold certifications like CSP (Certified Safety Professional — like me), CHST, and OSHA 30/510. I verify all certifications before placement.
Q: Can SafetyPro help with permanent hiring too?
A: Yes. Our recruiting services help fill permanent Safety Director and Safety Supervisor positions.
Making the Right Decision
After three decades in this profession, I can tell you there's no universal answer. The right choice depends on your operations, project pipeline, budget, client requirements, and strategic goals.
For many companies, the optimal solution combines both: maintaining core safety leadership through full-time staff while supplementing with temporary professionals during peak periods. This hybrid model delivers consistency, flexibility, and cost-effectiveness.
According to OSHA's business case for safety, companies save $4-$6 for every $1 invested in safety programs. That's a return I've seen demonstrated repeatedly. The question isn't whether you can afford to invest in safety — it's whether you can afford not to.
Take the Next Step
I've helped construction and industrial companies across Louisiana and the Gulf Coast optimize their safety staffing for nearly two decades. I understand your challenges because I've lived them — from my years in refineries and chemical plants to managing complex construction projects.
Ready to discuss your safety staffing needs? Schedule a free consultation to explore how SafetyPro's staffing, recruiting, and consulting services can support your safety goals while optimizing your budget.
Don't let safety staffing decisions hold back your business growth or put your workers at risk. Contact SafetyPro today at (800) 941-0714 or visit safetyproresources.com.
About the Author:
Lance Roux, CSP, is the Founder and Principal Consultant at SafetyPro Resources, LLC. He is a Certified Safety Professional with nearly 30 years of experience across petrochemical, construction, healthcare, chemical processing, refinery, power generation, and shipyard industries. Lance has served as Louisiana Area Director for the American Society of Safety Professionals, President of the Greater Baton Rouge ASSP Chapter, and Chairman of the Associated General Contractors of Louisiana Safety Committee. He has received ASSP Safety Professional of the Year awards at both chapter and regional levels.
Other Helpful Articles
Building a Cost-Effective Safety Program: Calculating Your True ROI
Fall Protection Rescue Plan Essentials for Roofing Contractors
The Benefits of Outsourcing to a Safety Consultant
Why Monthly Safety Management Matters for Compliance & Risk Reduction
