--- title: Industry Responds to the New OSHA Silica Rule description: How are industry & business leaders responding to proposed rule on crystalline silica? OSHA claims the new rule will save approximately 700 lives. Read more image: https://www.safetyproresources.com/hs-fs/hub/322414/file-605741872.png --- [Skip to content](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/industry-responds-to-the-new-osha-silica-rule#main-content) **Call Us Today! [(800) 941-0714](tel:(800)%20941-0714)** [![facebook](https://www.safetyproresources.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Atomic%20June%202026/Icons/facebook-color.png?width=24&height=24&name=facebook-color.png) ](https://www.facebook.com/safetyproresources/) [![linkedin](https://www.safetyproresources.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Atomic%20June%202026/Icons/linkedin-color.png?width=24&height=24&name=linkedin-color.png) ](https://www.linkedin.com/company/safety-pro-resources/) [![Safety_pro](https://www.safetyproresources.com/hubfs/Atomic%20June%202026/Image/Safety_pro.jpg) ](https://www.safetyproresources.com/) - [Home](https://www.safetyproresources.com) - [About Us](https://www.safetyproresources.com/about-us) - [Our Team](https://www.safetyproresources.com/our-team) - [Safety Staffing for the Gulf Coast](https://www.safetyproresources.com/safety-staffing-and-recruiting-services) - [Safety Jobs in Louisiana](https://www.safetyproresources.com/safety-jobs-in-louisiana) - [Services](https://www.safetyproresources.com/safety-management-services) - [AVETTA Compliance Services](https://www.safetyproresources.com/avetta-compliance-services) - [Safety Consultant Services](https://www.safetyproresources.com/safety-consultant-services) - [Safety Management Systems](https://www.safetyproresources.com/safety-management-systems) - [Construction Safety Management](https://www.safetyproresources.com/construction-safety-management) - [Safety Prequalification Database Management](https://www.safetyproresources.com/safety-prequalification-database-management) - [Custom Safety Management Services](https://www.safetyproresources.com/custom-safety-management-services) - [Monthly Safety Management Services](https://www.safetyproresources.com/monthly-safety-management-services) - [Safety Auditing](https://www.safetyproresources.com/safety-auditing) - [Safety Risk Management](https://www.safetyproresources.com/safety-risk-management) - [Employee Safety Training](https://www.safetyproresources.com/training) - [Safety Programs](https://www.safetyproresources.com/safety-programs) - [Blog](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog) - [Resources](https://www.safetyproresources.com/resources) - [How to ensure safety compliance](https://www.safetyproresources.com/how-to-ensure-safety-compliance) - [Testimonials](https://www.safetyproresources.com/testimonials) - [Contact](https://www.safetyproresources.com/contact) # Industry Responds to the New OSHA Silica Rule Post By  [ Lance Roux ](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/author/lance-roux) On March 25, 2014 [** ](mailto:?subject=Industry%20Responds%20to%20the%20New%20OSHA%20Silica%20Rule&body=Industry%20Responds%20to%20the%20New%20OSHA%20Silica%20Rule%20https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/industry-responds-to-the-new-osha-silica-rule) ****![osha silica rule](https://www.safetyproresources.com/hs-fs/hub/322414/file-605741872.png?width=280&name=file-605741872.png "osha silica rule")****How are industry and business leaders responding to a new proposed rule on crystalline silica?  OSHA claims that the new rule will save approximately 700 lives and prevent 1,600 cases of silicosis each year, but many in the construction industry are concerned that the rule is not economically feasible. Proposed Changes to the OSHA Silica Rule The express intent of the proposed rule is to lower worker exposure to crystalline silica, which causes silicosis, an incurable lung disease. Current standards for general industry allow up to 100 micrograms of crystalline silica per cubic meter of air.  For construction and shipyards, the standard is 250 micrograms of crystalline silica per cubic meter of air. The proposed OSHA Silica Rule will lower the exposure limit to 50 micrograms per cubic meter of air, in line with recommendations made by the National Institute for Occupational Safety and Health (NIOSH). In addition to lowering the exposure limits, the proposed rule includes provisions for the following. - Measuring silica exposure - [Reducing exposure](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/how-to-apply-oshas-hierarchy-of-controls-to-mitigate-safety-hazards) - Providing medical exams to workers with high exposure - Training workers about silica hazards -   - Construction Industry Opposition The public comment period for the proposed rule resulted in many comments against the rule, primarily from the construction industry. There were over 400 comments submitted and the opposition focused on the following key points: - OSHA underestimated the costs associated with enforcement of the rule  - Enforcement is not economically practical - Enforcement is not technologically feasible - Rule is based on outdated data - OSHA did not adequately study the affected industries - OHSA relied on false assumptions to develop the rule In its comments, the U.S. Chamber of Commerce pointed out that silicosis has been on a long-term decline and claimed that OSHA built their proposal for the silica rule based on incorrect assumptions that failed to take into account recent data on mortality and exposure rates. Support from Professional Associations The majority of the supporting comments for the proposed rule came from Professional Associations and other Safety and Health groups. The Associations that supported the proposed rule did so with conditions.  The National Industrial Sand Association supported the worker protection provisions but expressed concern that compliance with the new standards is not economically feasible for businesses. Health associations such as American Cancer Society and the American Public Health Association endorse the proposed rule with no objections.  The American Society of Safety Engineers is in agreement with lowering exposure limits but also conceded that compliance to the proposed rule is probably not economically feasible. What’s Next for the OSHA Silica Proposal Informal public hearings on the rule began March 18 and will run through April 4, 2014.  We will continue to monitor this issue. [![Free Checklist "How to Survive an OSHA Inspection"](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/322414/7f5a6758-15db-44fa-979d-e53299d237e6.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/322414/7f5a6758-15db-44fa-979d-e53299d237e6) [OSHA News](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/osha-news) [Regulatory News](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/regulatory-news) ### Search [![Need Safety Help? Schedule a Call with Us!](https://no-cache.hubspot.com/cta/default/322414/4bb32a3f-58af-476e-9881-265367c8eb33.png)](https://cta-redirect.hubspot.com/cta/redirect/322414/4bb32a3f-58af-476e-9881-265367c8eb33) ### Categories - [Safety Management (90)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-management) - [Workplace safety (62)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/workplace-safety) - [Safety Tips (45)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-tips) - [Safety training (41)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-training) - [OSHA News (30)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/osha-news) - [Compliance (28)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/compliance) - [Injury Prevention (27)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/injury-prevention) - [Fall Protection (24)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/fall-protection) - [Safety Audits (24)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-audits) - [ISNetworld (21)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/isnetworld) - [Accidents (19)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/accidents) - [Leadership (19)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/leadership) - [OSHA Inspections (17)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/osha-inspections) - [safety culture (16)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-culture) - [Human Factors (15)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/human-factors) - [Worker Safety (14)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/worker-safety) - [Accident Investigation (12)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/accident-investigation) - [Best Practices (12)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/best-practices) - [OSHA Recordkeeping (12)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/osha-recordkeeping) - [How to Choose a Safety Consultant (11)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/how-to-choose-a-safety-consultant) - [safety and health (11)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-and-health) - [Employee Training (10)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/employee-training) - [Safety Perception Surveys (10)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-perception-surveys) - [Mindfulness (9)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/mindfulness) - [Regulatory News (9)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/regulatory-news) - [SMS (9)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/sms) - [Safety Coaching (9)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-coaching) - [electrical safety (9)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/electrical-safety) - [safety leadership (9)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-leadership) - [Heat Stress (8)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/heat-stress) - [Injury Management (8)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/injury-management) - [safety systems (7)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-systems) - [Behavior Based Safety (6)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/behavior-based-safety) - [Corrective Action Plan (6)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/corrective-action-plan) - [Heat Illness Prevention (6)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/heat-illness-prevention) - [Job Site Safety (6)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/job-site-safety) - [PSM (6)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/psm) - [Safety Standards (6)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-standards) - [Commercial Construction (5)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/commercial-construction) - [Confined Space (5)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/confined-space) - [Residential Construction (5)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/residential-construction) - [Safety Staffing (5)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-staffing) - [Crane Safety (4)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/crane-safety) - [Environment (4)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/environment) - [Forklift Safety (4)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/forklift-safety) - [Safe Driving (4)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safe-driving) - [Safety Goals (4)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-goals) - [Safety Jobs (4)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-jobs) - [construction certifications (4)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/construction-certifications) - [safety manual (4)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-manual) - [Building Contractors (3)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/building-contractors) - [Hazard Communication (3)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/hazard-communication) - [Hurricane Planning (3)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/hurricane-planning) - [avetta (3)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/avetta) - [coronavirus (3)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/coronavirus) - [Construction Managers (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/construction-managers) - [Contractors (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/contractors) - [Drug Testing (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/drug-testing) - [GHS (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/ghs) - [Hazardous Energy (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/hazardous-energy) - [Hearing Conservation (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/hearing-conservation) - [Heat Illness Symptoms (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/heat-illness-symptoms) - [OSHA Violation Citations (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/osha-violation-citations) - [PPE (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/ppe) - [Reporting (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/reporting) - [Roadway Work Zone Safety (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/roadway-work-zone-safety) - [Safety II (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-ii) - [emergency (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/emergency) - [fire safety (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/fire-safety) - [ladder safety (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/ladder-safety) - [return to work (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/return-to-work) - [safety expert witness (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-expert-witness) - [safety myths (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-myths) - [trench safety (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/trench-safety) - [water accidents (2)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/water-accidents) - [Confined Space Training (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/confined-space-training) - [Dealing with the Media (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/dealing-with-the-media) - [Ebola (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/ebola) - [Environmental Compliance (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/environmental-compliance) - [Expert Witness (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/expert-witness) - [Fall Prevention (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/fall-prevention) - [Fatigue (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/fatigue) - [Fatigue Management (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/fatigue-management) - [First Aid (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/first-aid) - [Forklift Training (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/forklift-training) - [Grain Bin Safety (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/grain-bin-safety) - [Hospital Safety (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/hospital-safety) - [Hurricane Season (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/hurricane-season) - [ISO 45001 (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/iso-45001) - [LOTO (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/loto) - [Labor Law (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/labor-law) - [Legal (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/legal) - [Loading Dock Safety (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/loading-dock-safety) - [Louisiana Industry News (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/louisiana-industry-news) - [Networking (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/networking) - [Pedestrian Safety (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/pedestrian-safety) - [Quality Programs (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/quality-programs) - [Reporting CV-19 cases (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/reporting-cv-19-cases) - [Retail Safety (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/retail-safety) - [Risk Management (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/risk-management) - [Roofing Contractors (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/roofing-contractors) - [Safe + Sound Week (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safe-sound-week) - [Silica Safety (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/silica-safety) - [Software (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/software) - [Substance Abuse (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/substance-abuse) - [Suicide Prevention (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/suicide-prevention) - [Sustainability (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/sustainability) - [Tier 2 Reporting (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/tier-2-reporting) - [VPP (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/vpp) - [Violations (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/violations) - [Winter Weather (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/winter-weather) - [Workplace CV-19 cases (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/workplace-cv-19-cases) - [Workplace Harassment (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/workplace-harassment) - [Youth Workers (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/youth-workers) - [crystalline silica (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/crystalline-silica) - [ergonomics (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/ergonomics) - [excavations (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/excavations) - [fire extinguishers (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/fire-extinguishers) - [flu (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/flu) - [hand hygiene (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/hand-hygiene) - [handwashing (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/handwashing) - [health (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/health) - [incident rate (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/incident-rate) - [job safety analysis (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/job-safety-analysis) - [lockout tagout (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/lockout-tagout) - [process safety management (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/process-safety-management) - [safety coaching in the workplace (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-coaching-in-the-workplace) - [safety complacency (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-complacency) - [safety consultant (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-consultant) - [safety data (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-data) - [safety management system (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-management-system) - [safety staffing companies (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/safety-staffing-companies) - [work fatigue (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/work-fatigue) - [worker fatigue (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/worker-fatigue) - [worker's memorial (1)](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/topic/workers-memorial) [See all](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/industry-responds-to-the-new-osha-silica-rule#) #### Subscribe to Our Blog ## Leave a Comment ## Related Posts ## [OSHA Updates Heat Safety Rules:](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/osha-updates-heat-safety-rules) What Contractors Need to Know On April 10, 2026, OSHA updated its program for protecting workers from indoor and outdoor heat hazards. The 2022 program now uses four years of data.. ## [OSHA Compliance vs Certification: What Employers Should Know](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/osha-compliance-vs-certification-what-employers-should-know) I've investigated more workplace incidents than I can count over many years in this industry, and one of the most common misunderstandings I encounter is the confusion between.. ## [When Does OSHA Require a Safety Harness?](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/osha-require-safety-harness) Falls cause many work-related injuries and even deaths. In response, the Occupational Safety and Health Administration (OSHA) has established rules to better protect workers.. ![Safety Pro](https://www.safetyproresources.com/hubfs/Atomic%20June%202026/Image/Safety_pro.jpg) SafetyPro Resources, LLC is an independent safety consulting firm and is in no way endorsed, sponsored, approved by, or otherwise affiliated with ISNetworld®.  *ISN®, ISNetworld®, RAVS®, T-RAVS™ and MSQ™ are trademarks or registered trademarks of ISN Software Corporation. - [Home](https://www.safetyproresources.com) - [About Us](https://www.safetyproresources.com/about-us) - [Services](https://www.safetyproresources.com/safety-management-services) - [Blog](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog) - [Resources](https://www.safetyproresources.com/resources) - [Testimonials](https://www.safetyproresources.com/testimonials) - [Contact Us](https://www.safetyproresources.com/contact) #### SUBSCRIBE TO OUR BLOG! #### CONTACT US 4459 Bluebonnet Blvd. Suite A Baton Rouge, LA 70809 **PHONE:** [800-941-0714](tel:800-941-0714) **FAX:** [225-709-9474](fax:225-709-9474) © 2018 SafetyPro Resources, LLC - [RSS](https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/rss.xml) - [Policy and Terms](https://www.safetyproresources.com/policy-terms) - [Site Map](https://www.safetyproresources.com/site-map) ![](https://www.facebook.com/tr?id=326767381124517&ev=PageView&noscript=1) ![](https://dc.ads.linkedin.com/collect/?pid=449106&fmt=gif) ![](https://segment.prod.bidr.io/associate-segment?buzz_key=brandgen&segment_key=brandgen-592&value=) ![](https://segment.prod.bidr.io/associate-segment?buzz_key=brandgen&segment_key=brandgen-592&value=) ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "dateModified" : "2024-10-01", "datePublished" : "2024-10-01", "headline" : "Industry Responds to the New OSHA Silica Rule", "image" : [ "http://cdn2.hubspot.net/hub/322414/file-605741872-png/image_01.png" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/industry-responds-to-the-new-osha-silica-rule", "@type" : "WebPage" } } ``` ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "BlogPosting", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Lance Roux", "url" : "https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/author/lance-roux" }, "dateModified" : "2026-07-06T15:59:56.119Z", "datePublished" : "2014-03-25T13:30:00.000Z", "headline" : "Industry Responds to the New OSHA Silica Rule", "image" : [ "https://www.safetyproresources.com/hs-fs/hub/322414/file-605741872.png" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/industry-responds-to-the-new-osha-silica-rule", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://www.safetyproresources.com/hubfs/2012%20sp_logo_c-1.jpg" }, "name" : "SafetyPro Resources, LLC" } } ``` ```json { "@context" : "https://schema.org", "@type" : "Article", "author" : { "@type" : "Person", "name" : "Lance Roux" }, "dateModified" : "2020-6-18T08:20:00+08:00", "datePublished" : "2014-3-25T08:00:00+08:00", "description" : "How are industry and business leaders responding to a new proposed rule on crystalline silica?", "headline" : "INDUSTRY RESPONDS TO THE NEW OSHA SILICA RULE", "image" : [ "https://www.safetyproresources.com/hs-fs/hub/322414/file-605741872-png/image_01.png?width=280&name=image_01.png" ], "mainEntityOfPage" : { "@id" : "https://www.safetyproresources.com/blog/industry-responds-to-the-new-osha-silica-rule", "@type" : "WebPage" }, "publisher" : { "@type" : "Organization", "logo" : { "@type" : "ImageObject", "url" : "https://www.safetyproresources.com/hs-fs/hubfs/Safetypro-2018/Images/Safety_pro.jpg?width=208&name=Safety_pro.jpg" }, "name" : "SafetyPro Resources" } } ```